FAT LOSS vs. WEIGHT LOSS: PRIORITIZING FAT LOSS OVER 40

Photo: AI Image

I’ve been there, stepping on the scale and eagerly hoping to see that magic number. Back then, my goal was 47 kg, convinced it was the ultimate measure of success. Looking back now, I can see that even at 50 kg, I was still looking great. But here’s the thing: the scale doesn’t tell the whole story. In fact, when we first lose weight, it’s often just water, not fat.

I learned this first-hand on my own journey. I quickly reached my “ideal” 47 kg, but I was far from fit. I was what you might call "skinny fat," thin on the outside but not strong or healthy on the inside. My diet was a mix of fruits, veggies, and cookies, with almost no protein to speak of. The scale might have said I was doing well, but my body was telling a different story.

For women over 40, this distinction between weight loss and fat loss becomes even more critical. As we age, muscle mass naturally declines, affecting our strength, metabolism, and overall well-being. That’s why shifting the focus from weight loss to fat loss (when needed), prioritizing muscle preservation, and improving body composition leads to long-term benefits, including better energy, resilience, and vitality.

It’s important to emphasize that not all women over 40 need to lose weight or focus on fat loss. This guidance is for those who have specific needs or personal reasons for exploring these changes. Every woman’s body and journey are unique, and what matters most is feeling strong, healthy, and confident in your own skin.

Let’s dive deeper into why fat loss, rather than just weight loss, should be the primary goal for women in their 40s and beyond, and how this shift can support a healthier, more balanced approach to well-being.

Fat Loss: What Truly Counts

Fat Loss Improves Health More Effectively Than Weight Loss: Fat loss, particularly in the abdominal area, is linked to improved cardiovascular health, better insulin sensitivity, and reduced risk of type 2 diabetes. Simply losing weight by cutting calories or following a fad diet can result in muscle loss, which slows down the metabolism. Fat loss, on the other hand, supports overall health and metabolic function.

Preserving Muscle Mass is Crucial for Metabolism: Muscle mass naturally decreases as we age, and this decline accelerates after 40. Since muscle burns more calories at rest than fat, preserving or building muscle through strength training is essential for maintaining a healthy metabolism. Focusing on fat loss instead of just weight loss ensures that you’re retaining muscle while shedding excess fat.

Improved Body Composition: Fat loss leads to a healthier body composition, which is an important marker of health. A healthy body composition (i.e., a higher proportion of muscle mass compared to fat mass) supports strength, endurance, and mobility, all of which are important as you age. A simple reduction in weight doesn’t necessarily improve these aspects of health.

The Role of Fat in the Body: It's Not All Bad

Fat is often demonized, but the truth is, fat plays a crucial role in our body’s functioning. Body fat supports hormone regulation, protects vital organs, helps absorb vitamins, and provides the energy we need for daily activities. It’s also necessary for cognitive function and overall health.

There’s no need to aim for fat loss unless excess fat is interfering with health or well-being. This happens when fat accumulates, especially around the organs (visceral fat), which can affect our health and energy.

For women over 40, fat distribution tends to shift, and this fat can impact health markers like insulin sensitivity, cardiovascular health, and hormone balance. In these cases, focusing on fat loss rather than just weight loss becomes important.

The Drawbacks of Focusing Solely on Weight Loss

Muscle Loss and Slower Metabolism: Fad diets and extreme calorie restriction may lead to rapid weight loss, but much of this can be muscle mass. The muscle loss can slow down metabolism, making it harder to lose weight and increasing the risk of gaining it back. This is especially problematic for women over 40, whose muscle mass is already naturally declining.

Temporary Results: Extreme diets that focus on quick weight loss can lead to temporary results, but they rarely lead to sustainable fat loss. Weight often returns quickly once the diet ends, resulting in a cycle of yo-yo dieting. This fluctuation in weight can have negative impacts on both mental and physical health.

How to Focus on Fat Loss Instead of Weight Loss

Strength Training: Incorporating strength training exercises into your routine helps preserve muscle mass while promoting fat loss. Building muscle is particularly important for women over 40, as it helps maintain a healthy metabolism and keeps your body strong. (If you're curious about how to build a sustainable exercise routine in your 40s, read this article here for actionable tips to get started.)

Nutrition That Supports Fat Loss: Instead of focusing on calorie restriction, prioritize nutrient-dense foods that support fat loss. Foods high in protein, healthy fats, and fiber help maintain muscle mass and keep you feeling satisfied, while also promoting fat loss. (To learn more about the importance of a balanced diet for women over 40, read the article here)

Mindful Movement: Activities like walking, swimming, yoga, and cycling help burn fat without the risk of losing muscle. These activities contribute to overall fat loss, but pairing them with strength training and a balanced diet will maximize fat loss and improve body composition over time.

Focusing on fat loss rather than weight loss when needed, maintaining muscle mass, improving body composition, and supporting overall health are more important than simply seeing a lower number on the scale. A balanced approach that incorporates strength training, proper nutrition, and mindful movement will yield better long-term results for health and well-being.

Wellness "Wisdom", Continued ...

• Make Space to Thrive

• When Did Effort Become Uncool?

• Exercise is NOT a Trade OFF for Food

• Burning calories ≠ burning fat

• Eat Your Way to Better Hydration

• Beyond Diet Culture: Weight Management Without the Scale

• Understanding Emotional Eating

• Softness as Strength in Menopause

The information provided in this post is for educational and informational purposes only. It is not intended as medical advice or a substitute for professional consultation. Please consult a healthcare provider before making any significant changes to your diet, exercise, or wellness routine to ensure they align with your individual needs and circumstances.